Recent comments

  • Free Lunchtime talks at the Library explore childhood ailments   1 year 4 weeks ago

    More free press for the snake oil pushers... There always were and always will be people who believe anything...

  • Nelson about to celebrate Kootenay Pride   1 year 4 weeks ago

    Lol Witherton, I wonder how many people never finished your first paragraph.

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Witherton, I stand corrected -- but not by the materials you provided, which were Alberta law, not BC law.  I checked ... and whether or not the City of  Trail owns the bottom of Violin Lake depends on the terms of the original Crown grant of land.   If the lake was outlined in red in the original grant, then the City can own the lake-bottom.  If not, then it is owned by the Province.  It appears from the BC Land Act that the Provincial government is now keeping title to lake and stream beds for itself ... easier to give permits to mining companies to use them as tailings dumps that way  :-(   ...  Of course, the Province does keep title to all the water in lakes and streams, and makes various regulations that apply to the use of that water. The Federal government also has a say over some uses of lake and river water.

    As for the US, different states have different laws.  Some of them allow people to claim ocean beaches as "private".  Some American buyers of ocean-front land in BC have been very disappointed to learn that they do not own the beach in front of their property below the high-tide line.

  • Nelson about to celebrate Kootenay Pride   1 year 5 weeks ago

    I have no idea how our society has came to this... to let our children think that it's okay and acceptable to live like this. It's all they see now, it's all around them. There's nothing more harmful to our society and culture as we know it. It almost makes me weep thinking about what the future holds if things continue down this path... I wish we as a people could go back to living how we used to, when we were in harmony with nature and natural ways, instead of these immoral and unethical lifestyles.

    (Of course I'm talking about our fossil fuel obsession - what did you think I was talking about?)

    On the other hand, pride parades are always fun and it's great to see a community that comes out to welcome all walks of life. When we judge others, we do not define them, we define ourselves. Spread the love! Have a good weekend!

  • BCTF president sends teachers back to picket lines beginning this week   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Time to send a message to the BC libs that they will listen to. A message from big business, in other words from the people that have Christie Clark's personal phone number on speed dial, wherever she tries to hide.

    How do we do that? Well, it would be nice to see other unions join the teachers in a general strike, but contract language  generally prevents that. But parents (and often grandparents) can take family time off to take care of children who find themselves not in school as expected. Or, if it is safe to so, bring your kid(s) to work. Your employer doesn't like that idea? Tell them to phone Clark up to let her know how disruptive her fight against public education is to business. I bet you the Liberals would be back at the negotiation table and a deal made within a week.

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Thanks for the clarification. From the letter it seemed they were saying it was all private property. City owned property is not private, by definition. Of course the city can still choose to close it to the public.

  • BCTF president sends teachers back to picket lines beginning this week   1 year 5 weeks ago

    i wish the teachers success in their labour action, but it's hard to see it happening any time soon, simply because Fassbender and the Clarkista government are not interested in really negotiating seriously....they have an agenda....union busting....and they do that by making the teachers look bad in the eyes of the public, insofar as they are able to do so...



  • COMMENT: Lessons from Mount Polley   1 year 5 weeks ago

    thanks for this article, and i can see the mess the Clarkistas are in, with their eternal brown nosing of big Corporations....and their eternal cutting of jobs and effectivity, resulting in no real oversight of Big Business in B.C....

    unfortunately, although the Clarkistas are not so good at actually governing, and representing the PEOPLE of B.C...they are VERY good at lying propaganda which represents them as the saviours of B.C....which people in B.C. appear to believe in sufficient numbers to keep re-electing these Harpocrites in "Liberal garb"....

    these Neo Cons can not be trusted to run a home business, much less the government of our Province....and yet the voters are so stupid, or self serving that they vote them back in every me they are crooks, liars, and cheats...but to B.C voters, they appear to be "gold plated"'s totally beyond me....


  • Robin Williams made you uncomfortable? You have no idea.   1 year 5 weeks ago

    thanks Kyra for posting this article about Robin Williams, yourself, and mental must have been challenging to decide whether to go public with your own struggles with ADHD, PTSD, OCD, and so on...i was moved by your honesty, and i hope it helps your readers to realise that mental illness is very common in today's world (just as it always has been)....and that in general mentally ill people do not get the same kind of care, respect, and trust, that people suffering from any other "physical" disease would get....

    if you have cancer, no one holds it against you....if you have diabetes...the same....but if you are mentally ill (and so many actually ARE) don't dare to tell anyone, except perhaps close family members) because you KNOW it will negatively impact your life in society....

    what is needed is more people like you, Kyra, stepping up to the plate, and revealing that they too suffer from mental illnesses of various kinds....

    many great artists were/are mentally ill....depression, bi-polar, and so on...and in fact, without that illness, they may never have produced those exquisite masterpieces which are so valued today....Vincent Van Gogh springs IMMEDIATELY to mind in this case....

    it's long past high time that we discard the stigma which has always been attached to mental illness, and the people who suffer from it....

    thanks again Kyra for this excellent article about a widespread problem that is not going away anytime soon....



  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Hi Phil!

    The City of Trail is one of the property owners in the area. I believe this is the only property they have the right to police, unless they have some sort of arrangement with the other owners.


    Kyra Hoggan


  • Council candidate Charles Jeanes thinks Nelson should put a stop to growth   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Great stuff.

    Even if I don't agree with everything, it would be so refreshing to have someone in council who did view the world differently. 

    The point that I do definitely agree with is the false idea that unlimited growth is necessarily a good thing, or a net positive. My philosophy is that growth at all costs is a very harmful idea to the community and the feel of a place, especially Nelson.

    If you don't agree with that... imagine in 20 years Nelson looking just like Banff, or Whistler... I like Nelson exactly how it is right now. Much more development and growth, and I might not recognize this place anymore. And that would break my heart.

    A radical thinker or two in council would do wonders for the future of this city. That being said, as people get older, they are more wary of change, more wary of new ideas, and it's only older people who vote in these little city elections, so it will be the same old ideas promoting growth for eternity... so enjoy Nelson while you can, while it's still Nelson as we know it.

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Just wondering why the city of Trail is monitoring the Violin Lake area and cleaning up after trespassers? If it's private property shouldn't that be the owner's responsibility? Hell, I even clean up garbage and mow the lawn on city property that borders my property. I didn't know as a land owner I was able to call on the municipality to take care of problems on my property.

  • First Nations leaders shocked and saddened   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Harper is so out of touch with the real world.. His comments about the native women are about as sensitive as Obama saying Ferguson has nothing to do with race and is only a police matter. But Obama isn't that dumb. Harper on the other hand, is.

    The guy is clueless and embarrasing. Why would anyone vote for loser with so little understanding of the real world.. Ohh Canada I pity thee.

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 5 weeks ago

    Actually, Sara you're wrong on those accounts.

    aaand wrong about the US too, but not important

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 6 weeks ago

    "Zazzoo", you are  mistaken about the title to lakeshore property "below the high-water mark".  If someone owns ALL the property around a lake, they also own the lake-shore and the lake-bottom.  

    If three are two or  more private properties surrounding a lake, the property line generally divides the lake  (and its shores, and its bottom) equally among them.

    It's only on the ocean that the land below the high-water mark is public property ... and only in Canada, by the way.  It's different in the U.S. 

  • Upcoming traffic and parking changes in downtown Nelson, part 1   1 year 6 weeks ago

    One of the worst intersections I've encountered in North America...  I've been hoping for this for a long time..

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 6 weeks ago

    Well Zazzoo - unless you are planning to parachute in and then levitate out, when you "walk" into the Violin Lake area, you will still be trespassing. The entire lake area is private land no matter what mode of land transport you use. It sounds like a few slobby persons have been making a mess in that area and therefore ruining it for all.

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 6 weeks ago

    Below the high water mark, the land is actually crown land so if a person walks into the area and is below the high water mark you can't actually kick them out.

  • Visits to Violin Lake are actually trespassing   1 year 6 weeks ago

    Well if the city of Trail is actually going to log and not use this an another reason why a person should not use Violin lake. Please dont clear cut like you did 6 - 8 years ago. Hire a contractor thats not from the clear cut cutting days. Log for the future, not for greed.

  • Are you a racist? A simple test you can do at home. Part 1/2   1 year 6 weeks ago

    There's racism and there's the devastating effects of past racism, abuse, and disenfranchisement all at work here. All this needs addressing but it's not being addressed in anything even slightl approaching a satisfactory manner in this country. Money gets thrown at the problem, but the money is flung while the thrower's eyes are turned away. Why?

    I hope you're not seriously suggesting that the 'racism' an immigrant from Japan might occasionally encounter from some inbred idiot on the street is even in the same ballpark as what native people face daily when applying for jobs, looking to rent an apartment, or hoping to be served in a restaurant. I have friends from various racial backgrounds and have asked them about their experience of racism and they've always replied that 'occasionally' someone might say something insensitive. Some can't come up with anything. Compare this with the daily experience of native people.

    You agree with me that native people 'do worse' than immigrants from different racial backgrounds and yet the best you can come up with is to try to argue that the reasons are somehow merely demographic in nature. I suppose my question to you is, 'why struggle so hard to come up with an explanation of this sorry state of affairs that doesn't incorporate the elephant in the room?'

    This goes back to my original piece and the idea that, for us not to think of ourselves as racists, we, as non-natives, are forced to come up with whatever 'non-raced-based' reasons we can to explain the Third World condtions this part of our population live in. Why not just accept that native people continue to suffer in this country beause...we're willing to let them suffer?

    As to my last paragraph, I'm sorry I wasn't clear enough for you. I'll try to do better when I write the second part!--ed.

  • Are you a racist? A simple test you can do at home. Part 1/2   1 year 6 weeks ago

    It isn't as easy as looking up stats for rural white people and rural natives. Many rural white towns exist only because they provided economic opportunities and people migrated there. So it's a no brainer those communities will be better off than communities where people historically lived off the land with limited trade,  but which now don't provide jobs that can afford a modern lifestyle. I was talking about non-native towns that lost their main economic drivers several generations ago and are situated remotely. I doubt people growing up in those towns fare too well. But at least they are not dealing with the psychic aftermath of residential school or colonization.

    As for urban natives, there are still several factors working against them. The ones who migrated there probably did so to escape poor conditions where they grew up. Those conditions they grew up with often give them lasting disadvantages that they have to overcome which other urbanites don't. They also have to deal with cultural displacement, and yes they still have to deal with racial prejudices.

    Natives that grew up in urban Native communities might still have to deal with historical repercussions of residential schools and disenfranchisement. But on the whole, members of urban situated bands are better off than the average Native.

    As I've said before I do think Natives face racism, but I don't think that can explain their current situation. After all, many other immigrant groups face racism yet manage to do better than the indigenous population.


    I don't get your last paragraph at all. I hope your next article is a bit clearer on the many points you bring up in it.

  • Are you a racist? A simple test you can do at home. Part 1/2   1 year 6 weeks ago

    This is a question that could be answered by Statscan, I imagine. If one looked at remote, rural Canada, would native and non-natives be doing roughly equally well? I'm pretty sure not. And native people in urban centres chock full of opportunities are doing terribly as well.

    To claim that I'm making 'vague' accusations of racism isn't really fair since the sort of attitudes I'm talking about are necessarily 'vague' in that those who hold them will tend to deny them, given the cultural mandate for egalitarianism that the great majority of us pay lip service to in this society. Some of my best friends are...we all know the story.

    Another imagination excercise. Think of the last charity appeal you saw from sub-Saharan Africa with all those black kids and their bulging bellies and pleading eyes. Then try to imagine the same appeal populated by blonde-haired, blue-eyed tykes. It's an impossibility. This ties into the idea that the absurd concept of 'race' (of no more instrinsic signifcance than hair colour) is actually a function of capitalism in that the 'races' that get oppressed are the economic underperformers, historically. Racism is the outgrowth of the capitalistic world view--that there are 'winners' and 'losers' in life and that this is somehow natural and acceptable. But it's not.

    So there I go...starting on part 2 here in the comments section! Next week....--ed.


  • Are you a racist? A simple test you can do at home. Part 1/2   1 year 6 weeks ago

    I don't quite buy that Natives' current problems are due to racism or active oppression. If you've ever wandered into some of Canada's or the U.S.'s more remote communities that suffer chronic high unemployment due to lack of major industry, I'm sure you'll see that those citizens also have to cope with all sorts of disadvantages, regardless of race. High alcoholism, drug abuse, sexual abuse, poor health (physical and mental)...

    My point is that those disadvantages don't stem from race, just poor location, and for most of its citizens, the bad luck of growing up in such a disadvantaged community makes them in turn disadvantaged. Of course remote rural areas are overrepresented by Native people compared to other racial groups. Hence the fact statistics might make this look as a racial problem.


    And that's a big problem I see, but rarely see addressed:  that Native communities are spread pretty much all over Canada and as such are not always close to areas that offer much economic activity to support a community as we want and expect in a modern industrial age. And that's where I see a difference between racial groups: white people are more likely to uproot themselves and seek a better place to live. This is due in part to the fact they haven't lived there for as long (although there are certainly many small "white towns" that have existed for many generations), but also because non-indigenous populations see themselves as belonging to a greater cultural community than their local population. Whereas for a Native to leave their community, they risk loosing touch with their local tribe/nation and that culture, even if there are lots of Natives accross the continent because they are not all one cultural group despite their shared racial heritage. This is a problem, but it is NOT one of oppression or racism. It's also not an easily tackled problem. 

    As an aside, calling people passively racist is not a solution to anything and only serves to raise shackles, potentially even engendering racism. Let's look at actual disadvantages, let's try to remedy them, and if it is warranted let's look if race plays into it, but also HOW race plays into it, rather than merely doing some finger pointing calls of vague racism and oppression. 

  • Adams and Cherbo balk at proposed cuts to council expense accounts   1 year 7 weeks ago

    You ladies and gentlemen ought to be ashamed of yourselves! 

    Do you really need to have the city pay for your clothes? 

    i'd guess each of you is gainfully employed, or comfortably retired. 

    To ask the city to buy your wardrobe is unreaso-able and grossly greedy! 

    Instead of the city paying for your sartortial splendour, that money ought to go to the food bank or other charitable institutions. 

    For shame! BUY YOUR OWN CLOTHES!

  • Adams and Cherbo balk at proposed cuts to council expense accounts   1 year 7 weeks ago

    Sure hope the next election sees some fresh faces among the candidates!